Honestly, as a Chinese student, I never used neither
facebook nor google+ before I came to United States. I started to use facebook
at the first day that I came to United States with huge passion, but it cool
down very quickly. People believe facebook is the symbol of “social media”,
what if this media operate without “social”? For most Chinese students, they
can’t add to many friends when they are in China, because of the Chinese
firewall. Their friends even can’t register. However, Chinese students have a
lot of alternatives.
This is the “Global Top 15 social
networking sites” (ranked according to the number of active users) in
2013/4/26. From No.5 Sina Weibo to No.11 Tudou, all of them are Chinese
website. Even Wechat, a chinese social media smartphone app, ranked 5th
in the most-used smartphone apps in the world.
Chinese students
may have 600+ friends in their Renren(a popular Chinese social networking
website) friends list, but they can only add 20 to 40 Chinese friends or 10 to
20 foreigner friends. Maybe they will start to use facebook 2 years later; at
that time they may have a lot of foreign friends. Currently, I use facebook
only if some shop website or some apps need me to link or like it. I know it is
very sad.
G+ was launched at 2011, it has 150 million registered members. 110 million are active register users.
2)
57% of Facebook’s users are female. Their sex
radio is balance. The average age of
users is 37. They like “liking” very much.
67% of G+’s users are male. Some of them are engineers of Google. The
average age of G+’s users is 28.
This is the simple competitive analysis for facebook and
google+.
To compare this
two social networking, I spend two days to try it. All the follows are my
personal user experience as a fresh user for these two.
1)
Surface: I have to admit that I love the surface
of G+. It is more laconic, directional, and cute. Facebook just put everything
together, which makes me loss my interest to read more.
2)
Language: Facebook is much more easy for me to
set the language. (I’d like to test whether it support Chinese, but I will keep
it in English.) It took me 5 minute to set the language in G+. Interesting is,
all the things came out in Chinese at first. But I’d like to read it in
English. I can’t find where to set language. Then I recognized that I should
try it in my google account pages. I think that the starting point of G+
designer is good. They try to make it more convenient for users. However, what
if the users need two or more different language in different google products?
3)
Post/ update status: I really like to post
things at G+, because I can find what I exactly want to add with the lively
icon. Facebook only has several words: update status and add photos/video.
There is another thing I have to mention that no matter when I want to post
something, G+ always remind me which “circle” I’d like to post, which gives me
a lot of privacy protection. Facebook do has something similar, but they never
remind people to do so.
4)
Circle and friend: I don’t have so many friends
neither facebook nor g+. Both of them allow people divided their friend into
different group. Friendship in g+ is a kind of one-way. I add somebody, just
because I want to read what he or she post. If he doesn’t want me know
something, just post something to specific circles. Friendship is more reality.
It is bidirectional. We send request and wait for their response to add
friends.
5)
Mobile and others. Because of the large users of
Android system and gmail, I believe G+ has a great platform and potential
users. They need to develop the market. Google also has various products, such
as blogger. I think they need to be more closely linked, instead of only a
hyperlink or photo for the uesrs to their homepage. On the other hand, facebook
is mature. There are so many website and apps require their users to link to
facebook. They always provide inviting rewards. I’ll keep link them to my
facebook!
